Jacksonville University

Being inducted alongside teammate Sarah Simon, Sarah Sigrest Caffrey, became one of the first Jacksonville softball players in the Dolphins' Hall of Fame. Prior to being inducted into the JU Hall, Sigrest Caffrey was a 2024 inductee into the ASUN Hall of Fame. She set program standards for the Jacksonville softball team by dominating inside the circle as a pitcher. She holds the program’s all-time record for wins and saves and ranks second in strikeouts. She earned a career ERA of 1.97 which is second best all-time. Her single-season records for wins and ERA in 2011 helped lead Jacksonville to its first Atlantic Sun championship and culminated in the first NCAA Postseason appearance for the Dolphins.
Her career records following the 2026 softball season are:
- 4th in all-time appearances 
- 3rd in all-time innings pitched
- 1st in all-time wins
- 2nd in all-time strikeouts
- 1st in all-time saves
- 2nd in all-time ERA
- 2nd in single season pitching appearances (2011)
- 7th in single season pitching appearances (2012)
- 8th in single season pitching appearances (2009)
- 2nd in single season innings pitched (2011)
- 4th in single season innings pitched (2012)
- 1st in single season wins (2011)
- 3rd in single season wins (2012)
- 8th in single season wins (2009)
- 1st in single season strikeouts (2012)
- 2nd in single season strikeouts (2011)
- 10th in single season strikeouts (2009)
- 1st in single season ERA (2011)
- 9th in single season ERA (2012)
- 1st in single season shutouts (2011)
- 2nd in single season shutouts (2012)
- 1st in single season complete games (2011)
- 3rd in single season complete games (2012)
- No-hitters pitched in 2009 & 2012

ASUN Accolades:
- 2011 ASUN Pitcher of the Year
- 2011 ASUN First-Team honoree
- 2009 ASUN All-Freshman Team
- 2011 ASUN All-Tournament Team
- 2011 ASUN Tournament MVP
- 2012 ASUN All-Tournament Team
- 9th all-time in single season wins
- 1st in league ERA in 2011
- 1st in league games started in 2011
- T1st in shutouts in 2012
- 5X Pitcher of the Week

National Awards:
- 2011 NFCA All-Region 2nd Team member